He was so eager to show me his cock in his dad's 78' Cadillac we rode in. I thought he had a big monster cock because he was so handsome, tall and he was very popular around the way. I got my hopes up high and thought I would see a big huge beautiful cock. NO! He unbuttoned his pants with so much confidence. He closed his eyes and told me to touch it. I reached over without looking and tried to rub his cock. I couldn't feel it, it was that small. I had to look over because my hands wouldn't guide me. His cock was about 4 inches and very thin. I looked at him, and said wow. He said "Is everything ok?" I was so upset, I wanted to get laid that night. I knew I would not have fun with this short midget dick. I wanted something big that I could feel. I had an attitude the rest of the evening. I told him I had to go home and meet someone. I lied, I was so disappointed that he had a tiny cock. I called my best friend the next day and we both laughed and joked about his tiny cock. My bff said "Well at least you didn't go back to his place or go to a hotel". I was glad I didn't. We both would have been upset because I refused o fuck him. He called me a few more times and I always declined his calls. After a year, the joke was out about him and his little cock. All the girls began to gossip about his little tiny cock.
